Did the Tragic Death of Judy Garland Really Spark the Stonewall Uprising?

AP Photo

Judy Garland died on June 22, 1969, at the age of 47. The premature passing of this Hollywood darling was mourned worldwide — most famously at the Stonewall Inn, a gay bar in New York City’s Greenwich Village. Being a gay icon, it was supposedly grief over Garland’s fatal overdose which inspired the Stonewall patrons to riot in the streets: a historic event that kicked off the LGBTQ+ movement on a mainstream scale. But more than fifty years later, that story is contested. So let’s take another look at the death of Judy Garland, consider its true cultural consequence.

Judy Garland’s life was defined by the heights of success and the pits of addiction. Born Frances Ethel Gumm in 1922, Garland hailed from Grand Rapids, Minnesota. As part of a musical family, Garland’s talent was noted early on. By the time Garland was four years old, the whole family relocated to California dreaming of stardom for the Gumm sisters, who began going by a new name: the Garlands. Garland’s mother, reportedly, pressured her daughters on the Vaudeville path to the point of full-on abuse. In 1967, Garland told Barbara Walters: “[My mother] would sort of stand in the wings when I was a little girl and if I didn’t feel good, if I was sick to my tummy, she’d say, ‘You get out and sing or I’ll wrap you around the bedpost and break you off short!’ So I’d go out and sing.”

The Early Life of Judy Garland

When Judy was only 13, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer offered her a contract after a single screen test at the eager behest of MGM head Louis B. Mayer. (The infamous movie man also sexually harassed, and possibly abused, the young Garland for years.) Early in her career, Garland was marketed as a more realistic alternative to her glamorous Hollywood contemporaries. Often, she played the girl-next-door type opposite co-star Mickey Rooney. This unique identity would eventually color her take on the tale, A Star Is Born. During her comeback era, Garland would star in the original remake of this 1937 classic.

But the “ugly duckling” marketing-led Judy Garland to become seriously self-conscious. Her teen years marked the very beginning of the mental health issues that would continue to plague Garland. That stress was heightened by her non-stop performances, which in turn were intensified by MGM’s dangerous and shocking malpractice. The movie studio relied on amphetamines. a.k.a. “pep pills” to power their performers throughout exhausting shoots. Wanting to come down from the high and fall asleep, these actors typically sedated themselves with barbiturates. Even before Garland signed with MGM, it’s believed that her own mother, Ethel Marion Milne, mother-daughter hooked on this deadly habit; Garland even called her mom “the real Wicked Witch of the West.” The actress’s cyclical reliance on drugs is explored in the Oscar-winning biopic Judy, starring Renée Zellweger.


‘The Wizard of Oz’

For her unparalleled breakthrough role as Dorothy, Judy Garland cemented her place in movie history and earned her only Academy Award: the Academy Juvenile Award honoring her 1939 work on both The Wizard of Oz and Babes in Arms. Garland was just 16 years old when filming the timeless fantasy tale that still defines our collective imagination.

Judy Garland’s Personal Life

Following the smashing box office success of The Wizard of Oz, Garland began collaborating with the director Vincente Minnelli — who became the second of Garland’s five husbands. (First, Garland had married David Daniel Rose when she was 19 years old. They divorced in 1944.) Minelli directed his wife in Meet Me in St. Louis and the couple had their only child, daughter Liza Minnelli, in 1946. Soon after, Garland starred in Easter Parade and Summer Stock.

Vincente Minnelli and Judy Garland divorced in 1951, and the actress married Sidney Luft one year later. Sid Luft became Garland’s manager and they had two children together, Lorna Luft and Joey Luft. But In 1963, Garland divorced her third husband on the grounds of mental cruelty and physical abuse. Two years later, Garland married her tour promoter, Mark Herron. During their years together, both Garland’s health and career deteriorated. Garland wed her final husband, night club manager Mickey Deans in February of 1969. But the marriage would last only four months. In June of that year, Judy Garland was found dead in her London home.

The Death of Judy Garland

Judy Garland’s rise to fame might have seemed like an American fairy tale. But her sad death illuminated just what a toll the lifestyle took on Garland. Never quite able to enjoy her fame and fortune, Garland was always surrounded by conniving show business types and hampered by substance abuse. 12 days after her 47th birthday, on June 22, 1969, Mickey Deans found Garland dead in the bathroom of their rented home in London. The coroner identified the cause of death as an overdose of barbiturates. Believing the death was accidental, Garland’s doctor noted that she used the barbiturates as sleeping pills and another bottle of 100 barbiturate pills remained unopened.

At the time, Judy Garland was practically broke. Liza Minnelli was left to pay off her mother’s monumental debts with the help of family friend Frank Sinatra. As a result, most of what was recorded in Judy Garland’s final will could not be bequeathed.

Judy Garland’s body was embalmed and her remains traveled to New York City. On June 26, 1969, an estimated 20,000 New Yorkers came to pay their respects at the Frank E. Campbell Funeral Chapel in Manhattan. Two days later, the LGBTQ community gathered and the Stonewall Uprising erupted, purportedly as a response to the tragic end of her life.

The Stonewall Uprising: Re-examining the Legend

Judy Garland was a certifiable gay icon, for both her solidly camp status and publicly troubled history. Becoming something of a character herself, the actress was both sympathetic and supremely talented. When asked about the fandom phenomenon in 1965, Garland said simply, “I couldn’t care less. I sing to people!”

Today, most historians disagree that Judy Garland’s death is truly what galvanized Stonewall: a watershed moment in the gay liberation movement. As the story goes, the gay dive bar was packed with people on June 28, 1969. Undercover police officers, known as the Public Morals Squad, then stormed the establishment. Many people say that drag queen activist Marcia P. Johnson incited the full-out frenzy at the Stonewall Inn by throwing a cocktail glass. But witness accounts, including testimony from Johnson herself, have debunked that theory.

According to The New York Times video, “The Stonewall You Know Is a Myth. And That’s O.K,” the first glass could be likely thrown by another gender non-conforming person: Stormé DeLarverie. Similar confusion surrounds who threw the first “brick,” and even, whether any bricks were actually thrown! Regardless, the police raid fired up the crowd who fought back. Protests escalated on the surrounding streets, arguably to the point of riots. In the following weeks, demonstrations were held around the country in solidarity.

The only written account connecting the death of Judy Garland to the events at the Stonewall Inn was published in The Village Voice by Walter Troy Spencer, a right-wing columnist meaning to belittle the growing movement. Many experts view Garland’s connection to the historic protest as laughable, since Spencer’s motive was to trivialize the pain and physical harm faced by gay people. In the New York Times video, the queer writer Tourmaline poses the question, “Historical erasure is real. How do we tell a history of something when our lives aren’t in archives?” Fifty years later, certain inquiries like “Who threw the first brick?” are still complex. But as for the question “How much did Judy Garland factor into it?” the answer looks like very little. It seems that word of mouth alone formed a place for Judy Garland within the timeline of gay pride zeitgeist.

Watch: All of Hollywood Icon Judy Garland’s Husbands, Listed

What do you think?

Police Officers Suspended After Pepper Spraying 9-Year-Old Girl, Incident Caught on Body Camera

Woman Brought Animal Shelter’s Kill Rate From 100% to 0%