Grace VanderWaal made Jimmy Fallon feel like the oldest man alive when she didn’t get his ’90s boy band reference

YouTube/Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon (Grace VanderWaal)

Videos by Rare

Videos by Rare

We know Grace VanderWaal can sing with a ukulele, but can she sing with a mouth full of marshmallows?

The “America’s Got Talent” winner appeared on “The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon” this week, and he put her up to the ultimate challenge.

Fallon went first and shoved his face full of marshmallows. He started with Lady Gaga’s “Poker Face” and when VanderWaal couldn’t guess that he moved on to Taylor Swift’s “Shake It Off,” which of course she knew.

VanderWaal made us all feel old when she couldn’t guess the obvious “Bye Bye Bye” by N*SYNC, even though Fallon was doing the dance! When he told her the answer she said, “‘Bye Bye Bye?’ What?”

RELATED: Read this woman’s story as she live tweets sitting next to a creepy doll on a plane

“I’m so old! I’m so old! I’m so old!” Fallon said slamming his head on the desk. Same, Jimmy Fallon. Same.

VanderWaal was up next for the advanced version of Chubby Bunny.

She stumped Fallon on Katy Perry’s “Roar” but, after the game ended she tried for one more, Drake’s “Hotline Bling.”

We bet she’ll bring this game to her next slumber party!

What do you think?

Hear the story behind Dolly Parton’s “gift that keeps on giving”

Kane Brown speaks out for the first time after the death of his papa